Best Type of Mirror For a Home Gym Pros and Cons Explained

Confused by the types of gym mirrors that are out there? What is the best option and why? You can find it here with all the pros and cons. 

The best mirror for a home gym is a large glass mirror. These offer superior reflection, durability, and aesthetics, while glass mirror tiles provide similar benefits with some downsides at a lower cost. Large framed mirrors are cheaper but lack safety features and are usually too narrow. 

Below you can find why certain types of mirrors are better for a home gym than others. Some key details make certain types much better or worse. While one type might be a bit cheaper, for not much more money you can have a much better experience. 

The Best Type Of Mirror For a Home Gym

There are a surprising amount of mirrors out there. Not all of them are suitable for a home or garage gym though. Gym mirrors should have some safety features like being tempered and having a safety backing to prevent dangerous situations. 

There are four main types of mirrors to be aware of that are used as gym/workout mirrors;

  • Acrylic mirror tiles
  • Glass mirror tiles
  • Frameless large glass mirrors
  • Large Framed Mirrors
  • Smart mirrors

There are some other types like:

  • Framed mirrors
  • Mylar sheets
  • Several DIY solutions
  • Mobile gym mirrors
  • Backlit Mirrors

But if you’re looking for a good home gym mirror, those aren’t the ones to look at. Here are your options from best to worst. 

Choosing the right type of mirror isn’t the only important factor when choosing a gym mirror. Here you can find 6 more factors that help you pick the right one.

1. Large Glass Mirrors

While your budget and needs may vary, for most home gyms it’s recommended to use large glass mirrors. And what is meant by large is; at least 3’ x 5’ (36” x 60”) or larger. 

They are more expensive than glass or acrylic tiles but they provide a better reflection without gaps, fewer visual distortions and just look better. 

They can be a challenge to install but once they’re on your wall, they’ll last forever as long as there are no big impacts. And since there can be impacts to the mirror in a gym, it’s advisable to use mirrors that are made from 6 mm tempered glass with safety backing. 

Glass doesn’t scratch easily like acrylic and can be cleaned with regular household products. 

Want to find the best mirror in this category? Click here to find a great gym mirror that is high-quality, strong, and large enough.

2. Glass Mirror Tiles 

The second best option for a home gym is to use glass mirror tiles. They have many of the benefits of large glass mirrors; durability, reflective clarity, and ease of cleaning, but are cheaper per square foot. They are also available in tempered versions which should be on your checklist for gym mirrors.

The big tradeoff here is that while they’re cheaper, you have to deal with a lot of seams between the tiles. By using tiles without a beveled edge and being very precise while mounting them you can minimize the seams but they’ll always be there. 

The installation is also more difficult. While the smaller tiles are easier to handle than a big mirror sheet, tiles are usually glued instead of mounted with hardware. That means the wall surface has to be appropriate and you’ll have to be very precise. One tile out of place will impact the whole mirror with crooked seams, etc. 

Also, if one tile is at a slightly different angle than the rest, you’ll get weird visual distortions. 

You can find a more in-depth article on the pros and cons of using tiles as gym mirrors here.

3. Large Framed Mirrors

You might have noticed frameless mirrors made from tempered glass are quite pricey. Can’t you just use a large framed mirror for a bedroom or bathroom? 

You can, and they are a lot cheaper but it’s important to be aware of the drawbacks. 

  • These mirrors are not made from tempered glass: Normal glass breaks into large, very sharp shards. Tempered glass breaks into small, less sharp pieces which is much safer. 
  • They usually don’t have safety backing: Safety backing helps keep the shards in place if the mirror is broken. 
  • They are too narrow: Gym mirrors should be at least 36” wide for a good view. Most framed mirrors are much narrower than that, cutting off part of your view. 
  • The frame makes using multiple mirrors difficult: You might think you can solve the width issue by hanging two next to each other. The frame means you’ll have a big gap in the middle which is not great. 

Framed mirrors do provide a great reflection quality without distortions just like proper gym mirrors and glass mirror tiles. If you’re not convinced, here is an article comparing framed and frameless mirrors for a garage gym.

4. Acrylic Mirror Tiles

Acrylic mirror tiles are lightweight, shatter-resistant, and very cheap. They are also easy to handle. Why are they not higher on this list? 

That’s because acrylic mirrors have some big drawbacks. 

Acrylic mirrors don’t offer the same level of reflective clarity as glass mirrors. They can scratch more easily and require more frequent cleaning but the cleaning is when they scratch. Over time, they will become cloudy from the scratching. 

Other than that they have the same drawbacks as glass tiles. There will be seams and mounting them has to be very precise. 

And since they’re very cheap but not that much cheaper than glass tiles or a framed mirror, those are the better choices. 

You can read more about the differences between gym and normal mirrors in this article.

5. Smart Workout Mirrors

It’s not really fair to put smart workout mirrors last on this list. They can be very good although they are usually too small to be a good mirror. It depends on what you want from your home gym if smart mirrors are appropriate. 

  • Pros: Smart workout mirrors combine a mirror surface with built-in technology, offering interactive fitness experiences, workout tracking, and access to workout content. They save space and provide versatility for different workout programs.
  • Cons: Smart workout mirrors tend to be more expensive compared to other mirror options. They rely on internet connectivity, which may affect the user experience. Limited customization options and potential technological glitches can be drawbacks.

The choice ultimately depends on your priorities. If reflective clarity, durability, and a nice appearance are crucial, large glass mirrors or glass mirror tiles are the best options. 

Smart workout mirrors are ideal for those seeking a tech-integrated fitness experience, but they come at a higher cost.

Home Gym Mirror Types Pros and Cons

If you’re not convinced about the right type for your garage gym yet, check out all the pros and cons of the different types of mirrors. 

Pros and Cons of Large Glass Gym Mirrors

Pros of Large Glass Gym Mirrors:

  • Enhanced Visibility: Large glass gym mirrors provide a wide field of view, allowing you to see your entire body during exercises. This helps in assessing form, posture, and movement accuracy.
  • Improved Feedback: The larger reflection surface enables better visual feedback on your workout performance. You can easily identify and correct any imbalances or flaws in your movements.
  • Spacious Appearance: Large mirrors create an illusion of a more spacious gym environment, making the space feel open and inviting. They contribute to an aesthetically pleasing atmosphere.
  • Enhanced Lighting: Mirrors reflect and distribute light, improving the overall illumination in the gym. This reduces shadows and enhances visibility, making your workouts safer and more enjoyable.

Cons of Large Glass Gym Mirrors:

  • Cost: Larger glass mirrors are generally more expensive compared to smaller ones. The increased material and installation costs can be a significant investment.
  • Weight and Installation Challenges: Large mirrors are heavier and may require additional support or professional installation. Mounting them securely can be a complex and labor-intensive task.
  • Space Requirements: Installing large mirrors in smaller home gyms or tight spaces may pose challenges due to limited wall space. You need to ensure that your gym area can accommodate the size of the mirror.
  • Vulnerability to Breakage: Large glass mirrors are more susceptible to breakage due to their size. Accidental impacts or mishandling can lead to shattering, which poses safety risks and requires replacement.

Pros and Cons of Acrylic Mirror Tiles

Pros of Acrylic Mirror Tiles

  • Safety: Acrylic mirrors are shatterproof and considered safer than glass mirrors. In the event of accidental impact or breakage, acrylic tiles are less likely to produce sharp, dangerous shards.
  • Cost-Effective: Acrylic mirror tiles are generally more affordable than glass mirrors. They offer a budget-friendly option for those looking to set up a home gym without breaking the bank.
  • Versatility: Acrylic tiles can be easily cut into various shapes and sizes, allowing for creative customization. They can be arranged in different patterns or used to cover specific areas, providing flexibility in design.
  • Impact Resistance: Acrylic mirrors have better resistance to impacts and vibrations compared to glass mirrors. They are less prone to cracking or breaking, making them suitable for home gym environments where accidental bumps or movements may occur.

Cons of Acrylic Mirror Tiles for a Home Gym:

  • Prone to Scratching: Acrylic mirrors are more susceptible to scratches compared to glass mirrors. Care must be taken during cleaning and maintenance to avoid using abrasive materials that could damage the surface.
  • Reflection Distortion: Acrylic mirrors may have slight distortions or warp in the reflection, which can affect the accuracy of visual feedback. However, this distortion is typically minimal and may not significantly impact most home gym workouts.
  • Less Clarity: Acrylic mirrors may have slightly less clarity and sharpness in the reflection compared to glass mirrors. This can affect the overall visual experience but may not be a major concern for functional purposes in a home gym.
  • Durability: While acrylic mirrors are durable, they are not as robust as glass mirrors. They may be more prone to long-term wear and tear, such as fading or yellowing over time.
  • Limited Size: Acrylic mirror tiles are often available in smaller sizes, which may require more pieces and seams to cover larger areas. This can result in more visible joints and a less seamless appearance.

Pros and Cons of Glass Mirror Tiles

Pros of Glass Mirror Tiles For a Home Gym

  • Durability: Glass mirror tiles are known for their durability and longevity. They are resistant to scratches, dents, and fading, making them suitable for high-traffic areas such as gyms.
  • Reflective Clarity: Glass mirrors provide excellent reflective clarity, offering a true and accurate representation of form, posture, and movements during workouts. They allow users to assess their technique and make necessary adjustments.
  • Aesthetics: Glass mirror tiles can enhance the overall aesthetics of a gym space. They create a sleek and professional look, adding a sense of sophistication to the environment.
  • Easy Maintenance: Glass mirrors are relatively easy to clean and maintain. They can be wiped down with glass cleaner and a soft cloth to remove smudges and dirt.
  • Customization: Glass mirror tiles offer flexibility in terms of customization. They can be arranged in various patterns and configurations, allowing for creative and unique designs within the gym space.

Cons of Glass Mirror Tiles For a Home Gym:

  • Fragility: Glass mirror tiles are more fragile compared to large glass mirrors or acrylic tiles. They can be prone to cracking or breaking if subjected to heavy impacts or mishandling.
  • Installation Challenges: Installing glass mirror tiles can be more complex and time-consuming compared to other options. It requires precise measurements, proper adhesives, and careful placement to ensure a secure and level installation.
  • Weight: Glass mirror tiles can be relatively heavy, especially when used for larger areas. This may require additional structural support or professional assistance during installation.
  • Cost: Glass mirror tiles are generally more expensive than acrylic tiles. The higher cost is attributed to the quality, durability, and reflective clarity of glass.

Pros and Cons of Smart Workout Mirrors

Pros of Smart Workout Mirrors:

  • Interactive Features: Smart workout mirrors are equipped with interactive features such as built-in screens, cameras, and fitness apps. These features offer a variety of workout options, virtual training sessions, and real-time feedback, enhancing the overall workout experience.
  • Guided Workouts: Smart mirrors often come with pre-loaded workout programs and provide step-by-step instructions for exercises. They can guide users through workouts, demonstrating proper form and technique, which can be beneficial for beginners or individuals who prefer structured guidance.
  • Tracking and Metrics: Smart mirrors can track various workout metrics such as heart rate, calories burned, and workout duration. This data helps users monitor their progress, set goals, and make adjustments to their fitness routines.
  • Customization: Smart workout mirrors allow users to customize their workouts based on their preferences and goals. They offer a range of workout options, from strength training to yoga, and can adapt to different fitness levels and needs.
  • Convenience: With smart mirrors, users can access a wide range of workouts and training programs from the comfort of their homes. This convenience eliminates the need to travel to a gym or hire a personal trainer, making it suitable for individuals with busy schedules or limited access to fitness facilities.

Cons of Smart Workout Mirrors:

  • Cost: Smart workout mirrors tend to be more expensive compared to traditional gym mirrors. The additional technology and features contribute to the higher price point, which may not be affordable for everyone.
  • Technical Issues: Like any electronic device, smart mirrors can experience technical glitches or software malfunctions. Users may encounter connectivity issues, software updates, or compatibility problems with other devices or apps.
  • Dependency on Technology: Smart workout mirrors rely on technology and an internet connection to access the interactive features and workout programs. If there are connectivity issues or power outages, the functionality of the mirror may be limited or temporarily unavailable.
  • Learning Curve: Using a smart workout mirror may have a learning curve, especially for individuals who are not familiar with the technology or the specific features of the mirror. It may take some time to get accustomed to the interface, apps, and settings.
  • Lack of Personalization: While smart mirrors offer customization options, they may not provide the same level of personalized attention as a human trainer. The feedback and guidance are based on algorithms and pre-programmed instructions, which may not address individual nuances or specific needs. It is often possible to get interactive personal training through smart mirrors but this costs extra of course. 


Hey, I'm Matt. Welcome to After working out in many different gyms for almost 20 years and helping people build their own home gyms, i've learned a few things i'd like to share with you.

Recent Posts